Kathryn’s Review of the Baltimore Show

Hi everyone!

I am so glad that I was able to attend the concert to experience the fire of James live! As a performer, producer, director, adjudicator and observer of music for so many years I do have a wealth of experience to draw from when critiquing these performances. Here goes…

Overall the performances were good. The sets were simple, the color combinations interesting and a bit funky and the costumes were adequate. The girls spent most of the night in sequined dresses and heels. The guys were more varied in suits, casual wear and rock attire. The band was very good and never missed a beat! But the sound mix and volume were much too loud and overwhelming for most of the singers. That did not have to happen. The producers have control on the board and I am disappointed that they allowed the background instrumentals to overshadow the singers.

James was the only one that could be heard consistently above the fray. When the girls sang back up they could not be heard. I deal with this all the time with my opera orchestras. The conductor has to remind them continually that they are the background music when the singers are performing. In opera the sound is not miked in the way that the AI performances are. What you hear is what you get, and therefore cannot be controlled at a sound board. In my opinion there is no excuse for such imbalance of sound in the Idol situation! I realize that in these cavernous arenas the sound production is always a challenge because without mikes the sound drops off right in front of the singer, but better balance is certainly possible!

Lauren was sick and did not perform. It would have been in the audience’s best interest for AI to have made contingency plans ahead of times for such occurrences and rehearsed additional songs for James and others to perform in such cases! They did not and the concert was 5 spots shorter. Disappointing!! It appears that everyone was in quite a hurry to get to NYC for GMA and the focus was on the GMA performance not this one. Not filling in Lauren’s spots kept the show much shorter and got them on their way more quickly. Too bad for those of us who shelled out our $ for a full show!

The audience was enthusiastic and engaged the entire time, but as you will see only a very few really excited them!

The girls opened the show with Born This Way and it was their best group song of the night. It was one of the few times that they could actually all be heard. They all looked beautiful and were very strong vocally. The arrangement allowed them each to be featured significantly. Most of the audience sat!

“The Pia show” continued with Empire State of Mind. Her voice was powerful. She looked lovely, but her performance skills are very elementary and the audience was underwhelmed. Most sat!

Then it was – wait for it – Pia and Stefano with California King Bed. The sound mix went haywire for this song and there was a lot of feedback and sound distortion. What I could hear was good – they have a nice balance together, but they had very little fire for each other or the audience. The audience sat!

Paul appeared next to sing Maggie May. He is so comfortable on stage and knows how to get the audience involved. He actually acknowledged the audience – what a concept – and got a lot of the audience on their feet for the first time. His vocals were vintage Paul and his movements quirky and a lot of fun!

Thia sang next – Who Says. She gives a very soft, vulnerable appearance. She looked lovely and sang well, but her movement was not terribly inspired. Her sound is a lot like Pia’s – just not as powerful! The audience sat!

The girls performed Tightrope next. This was not a favorite of mine. Again they looked lovely and the harmonies that I could hear were very good and their solos sections somewhat stronger. Just not very interesting IMO. The audience sat.

Stefano appeared next to sing Grenade. He received a really good reception. His vocals were terrific and he looked great in black and white. He seemed to connect fairly well with the audience.

Stefano joined all of the girls next to sing DJ Got Us Falling In Love. Stefano really got the crowd wound up and many stood. But the vocals were completely overwhelmed. Maddening!

All of the men (except Scotty) sang Animal next. James was first to appear to thunderous applause. The audience screamed and leaped to their feet in one spontaneous movement. It was so good to see! Wow! The arrangement was good and the vocals strong periodically. Most of the time the voices were overshadowed by the background instrumentals. Only James and occasionally Jacob could be heard consistently above the fray!

Naima was next to sing On the Floor. She was fantastic. Her vocals were strong and her African dancing was phenomenal. She is a marvelous performer when her dancing is incorporated. She has a very unique niche to fill! The audience went crazy for her dancing. She had many of them on their feet by the end of her song! Terrific!!

Pia is back next to sing her new single – This Time. Her vocals were very good. The song is not a favorite for me. The melody is uninspiring and at times monotonous. Her movement so limited and she does not reach out to the audience to engage them. The audience is not terribly responsive and sits. The clapping is tepid at the finish.

Firework is not sung as Lauren is sick. No announcement is made that she is sick until intermission.

Casey sings Smooth next. The crowd receives him enthusiastically and some stand. He plays the bass masterfully and his vocals are very creative – great scat! He plays very well to the audience and they are very appreciative. A lot of fun!! Some stand!

Haley joins Casey next for Moanin. A lot of distortion in the sound of this duet! It is a shame because Haley and Casey are an evenly matched pair vocally. Their scatting was very good and the ending terrific! Many stand by the end.

Next Casey sings Harder to Breathe. He is at ease once again, but very difficult to hear until the very end. His movement is very creative. And the background visuals are very effective – a kaleidoscope of white smoke signals. The audience is up and down.

Everyone (except Scotty) comes out to end the first half and sings Forget You. The bright pink outfits are a bit much on the men. But the arrangement is good and so are the vocals. Everyone but James is featured several times vocally and moves back and forth to center stage. He sings only once and stays stage left. I will address this later.

Intermission – An announcement is made that Lauren is ill. I speak to a lot of people at intermission. This is strong country music “country” in MD and PA and there are a lot of Scotty and Lauren fans attending. But everyone I spoke to loved James and wanted him at least in the final and a most thought he would win. Many complained about the push for Pia and felt she was like ice. When I asked who was on fire without hesitation it was James. All were hoping James would sing extra numbers in the 2nd half to replace Lauren’s – as everyone else, except James, Paul and Scotty, were heavily featured in the first half! It did not happen and there was a lot of grumbling after the show that it did not happen and that Pia dominated the stage.

Lauren’ 2 solos are gone as is the girls’ quartet, If I Die Young.

The lights go down for the second half and suddenly the guitar begins the music for Sweet Child o’ Mine. Everyone leaps to their feet spontaneously once again screaming and shouting for James. Many are on their chairs straining to get a glimpse of him and taking pictures. I am surprised that anyone got a video of James. They were very strict about not letting us record! He is everything that any of us have imagined. His entrance gave me chills! The energy from the crowd was so uplifting and the volume was ear splitting – and it never let up! James is the only one, including Scotty, who maintained this level of audience participation and energy level the entire time he was on stage. It has to be experienced to be believed. He was never still. His vocals were strong and matched the band’s sound note for note. His movement was mesmerizing! And he connects emotionally to the audience in a way the others cannot. He is so gifted, I cannot express this enough!

Next James sang Uprising. I was most interested in hearing this for pitch reasons. The tube videos of this have shown pitch discrepancies all tour long and pitch is one of James’ strengths. The audience continued its fevered pitch and he was magnificent. He put so much energy into this piece and his pitch was just PERFECT (when I returned home I found a video of Uprising on the Tube from Baltimore and again those pitch discrepancies appear on the recorded version even tough he was pitch perfect live). The mystery was solved for me – the sound distortion continues to be a problem in the piece as it records! As I have said many times, Uprising is very operatic in nature and is the most difficult piece anyone sings on the tour. (James has stated that he did not choose to sing the 2 songs he was given. He would had chosen differently had he been given the chance. He would never have chosen to sing “Uprising” 45 times voluntarily. And when he was so sick he should have been allowed to sing something else much less taxing). Both performances this night just confirmed everything I have thought about James’ capabilities. Experiencing him live just adds an extra dimension to an already outstanding, “one of a kind” performer.

Next dear Jacob comes out to sing Never Too Much. Well, apparently James’ performances are too much for Jacob’s performances. The audience disengages as soon as James leaves the stage. Jacob has very strong vocals and his movement on stage has greatly improved; but Jacob just cannot get them back! James has “left the building” and the audience has left with him and tunes Jacob out for the most part. I felt for Jacob. But it certainly emphasizes James’ power over an audience.

The girls join Jacob for You’re All I Need To Get By. The audience is still disengaged. Jacob has strong vocals and lots of energy, but the girls cannot be heard AT ALL. Bummer!

It’s Haley’s turn to sing House of the Rising Sun. Her vocals that I could hear were outstanding and the audience began to engage once again by the end. But her stage movement was very limited on this piece, and her vocals were very overshadowed.

Bennie and the Jets was Haley’s best vocal and best performance. Her movement was fairly creative and she got the crowd back on its feet by the end! Great job!

There was a big build up to Scotty and this country crowd was on its feet shouting and cheering until he finally appeared and the volume went through the roof, just as it had for James. He sang Your Man first. The crowd remained fairly engaged, but Scotty has very elementary performance skills and had trouble keeping them on their feet for his entire set the way that James did.

Next Scotty sang Are You Going to Kiss Me Or Not. This song is a better crowd pleaser. Scotty’s vocals are strong. He plays the guitar and most of the crowd is back up.

Scotty loses the audience with his single, I Love You This Big. Most of them sit. IMO the melody is monotonous and very uninteresting. The crowd apparently agrees, because they were not terribly engaged.

Lauren’s duet with Scotty is out and so the next song Scotty sings is Gone. This is Scotty’s best performance and the audience is the most engaged with him for it! A lot of energy for this final solo.

The show ends with a medley. I only saw James sing Here I Go Again alone as I was hurrying out the to find a place to meet James. Please watch this video

and especially look for the expression on the faces of the band members as James descends the stairs to the floor and really opens it up vocally. Their reaction to him says it all. It says this young man is just the best! He never ceases to amaze. This is a short but amazing vocal from James and his energy and use of the stage for even this brief moment is totally engaging. Audiences will flock to his performances for years to come.

Finally, I have to say that I was very glad that I went to experience all the singers but most especially James. He is a phenomenon. A very rare organic and naturally gifted performer who excels in all 3 areas: vocal technique, emotional interpretation and impact, and creative performance skills. This is why for the life of me I cannot understand why Idol so under used him in this production. They did and it is deliberate. It was very obvious to all attending. For his position in the final standings he has the fewest solos, duets, and absolutely no outstanding exposure in the group numbers. There is absolutely no excuse for it unless there was a falling out with someone who wanted to put James in his place. Well, they have only made James stronger in the eyes of his fans and audience members and made themselves look smaller. Shame on them for deliberately trying to silence such talent. It is small and childish. Perhaps James is a challenge at times to deal with. I don’t know. But if every performer who ever had a difficult moment was cast aside the stage would be a mighty empty place. I just want to shout from the mountain top to all who will hear:

James is such a blessing to the world of music and performance and such a wonderful example to all who struggle to rise above and for all of us who strive to be the best that we can be. Let his light shine and his voice soar! We will all be the better for it!

\,,/ Kathryn McCarney \,,/


27 thoughts on “Kathryn’s Review of the Baltimore Show

  1. What a good review and its what I thought they were doing. Like you its not going to hold James back with the response he’s getting from fans says it all. The only ones that will be hurt by this is the producer’s of AI.

  2. It was very obvious that James was not featured at the concert. I went to the Oakland concert. But without a doubt, James is a favorite of every crowd. IN Oakland, it was definitely Scotty (by a margin) James and then maybe Casey. Despite his limited appearances though, James really made the most of them. HIs short solo in “Forget you” is the best– most audible, most energizing solo in the piece and when he came out to sing in “Animal” the crowd went crazy upon appearance and every time he opened his mouth. His solos were incredible. He comes out, and suddently everyone finally knows they’re at a real, legit concert– really, that’s kind of what it is. As soon as I saw that Lyndsay Parker interview with James where he sang Skid Row, I knew something didn’t go well with Interscope or AI. He just didn’t have the same enthusiasm.Who knows, maybe James turned them down? Maybe they didn’t like the Gaga disses or James getting Bach talking about how AI didn’t ask for clearance. Maybe James broke some rules. All I can say, is you can’t keep James down– it’s impossible–he’s just too talented and too well-loved. Even many non-fans and music critics have recanted their previous stances and admiited that James was amazing at the concert. So, rock on, James! We can’t wait for YOUR music! You are a legend in the making!

  3. What a great review!! Your writing about James and his many gifts brought tears to my eyes, because it pulls together so much of what I think so many have been thinking about James…THANK YOU!!

    Thank you for describing the reaction(s) to James in such detail…that is a big part of why I like to watch the vids…to see others get that same great reaction I have every time I watch a James vid, etc.

    I completely agree about how James has been treated reguarding the tour…really shameful, but I think it works out for James cause as the saying goes, ‘Always leave them wanting more…’, and it is obvious ALL the crowds want MORE JAMES!! 🙂

  4. Yes, and I meant to add, THANK YOU, Kathryn, for the detailed review. I also should add, at the Oracle Arena in Oakland, I also thought the accoustics were pretty bad. The din or volume of the music overwhelmed many of the performances. Not James though 🙂

  5. I too was at the show. Song choice was as important as who’s singing. The Opening riff in Sweet child of mine is iconic, and that’s what got the crowd on it’s feet! There’s a great melodic guitar lead ….It Rocks!! It’s an arena song. Was it loud??? Maybe for AI fans. Not as loud as Gun’n Roses! James sings it very well! If he would have sung While my Guitar Gently Weeps they would have been seated. Poor Jacob gets the worse song of the night and has to follow James. Once Jacob does his 2nd song, people are loving it as soon as the background vocals kick in. A much better song. The 2nd worse song was the Tightrope song. What a horrible go-nowhere tune. The only reason it was better than Jacobs first, was the glitter dresses on 4 pretty girls under the bright lites. Another great song was Casey’s Santana song. He only started this playing base, but put it down. Most of the song he wasn’t playing, just singing. Another great job! Again it was the band kick’n in and it was one of their best songs of the night.

  6. Brilliant review as always, Kathryn. I’ve wondered how long it would take for James to snap the AI leash and dominate the stage against the wishes of the producers. I don’t think he would do anything to hurt his friends, but for someone with his passion, it has to be frustrating.

    • Lauren’s illness allowed him to shine alone in the final medley!! He clearly made the most of it! I am so proud of him for taking that bull by the horns! I am surprised that they allowed him to sing it alone. Someone must have slipped up!

  7. Kathryn – Your experience in Baltimore was exactly the same as mine in San Jose. Being the closest venue for James’ hometown of Santa Cruz, it was really disappointing that we did not get ‘more James’! I too found the sound production to be mediocre and unbalanced at best and bored with the multiple group medley’s. They were ‘all right’ but when you think about it, we all watched AI to see individual performances not cheesy group numbers! If they had allowed each vocalist 3-4 songs either grouped like 2 here then 2 there, it would have been more like a concert, I don’t know, may be with some of them we’d fall asleep, but the group stuff was a bore. Think of this – if they had James do an individual song right before intermission, beer sales would have been up! Exciting stuff!

    The overuse of Pia in so many productions and in backup and the underuse of James, Paul and Casey overall was sad. Agreed – shame on them – many people didn’t say anything – however, why wouldn’t they play on everyone’s talent? They DID NOT. For the people who had the most pleasing stage presence and you named them – Naima, Paul, James, Casey – the others do not. I don’t have anything against any of them, but agree whole heartedly in your reviews of their elementary performance skills. Where are the tour coaches anyway? Ryan Seacrest is pulling in mega bucks with this tour and they really should continually ensure entertainment – not sleepertainment….

    Something has gone awry with James and the relationship with AI, he doesn’t need to say much – you can see it in his persona. Sort of like the mega-star being caged within the machine. Why they don’t use him more is a slient mystery. But like you said, when you see James in concert – it’s ELECTRIFYING! Everyone in the building is ignited. He really has a wonderful relationship with the band, relates and involves the audience with his songs with his performance. That is what a great entertainer does. James may not be a ‘sure, no problem, I’ll do that’ more like ‘what if we do this and this to enhance the number’ – it appears that the AI Machine just doesn’t care – they have a corporate model to follow.

    In closing, may we all thank you Kathryn for putting forth the effort of this review and the other reviews you have written in the forum. I think alot of people see what you so eloquently write. James Durbin is an exploding star right before our us with his eye on the prize, to do what he loves to do with imagination, humility and hard work. We are all looking forward to following him and continue to support his originality and talent. Best, ~L

    • Very well said. I agree that there were too many group numbers and not enough of several of the singers individually. The usual model for this concert is that the number of solos increases with the final placement of the contestant. The overuse of Pia and the under use of James is what really showcases the huge discrepancy. I agree that something happened while the show was being put together and James became the odd man out because of it! Doing that just reveals a vindictive nature and shows that TPTB did not have have the the best interest of James or the audience at heart!

  8. It is surprising they don’t have a couple of backup songs. Casey’s Have you Ever Seen The Rain, Haley’s Rollin in the Deep, James singing Carol king, and get rid of the New York song from Pia, and replace it with River Deep. It would be an even better show. Overall, I enjoyed it and all of the singers did well.

    • Jack– I really enjoyed both of Casey’s performances at Oakland, as well. I enjoyed most of the performances (most impressed me more live, than on the show), just those two (James and Casey) really stand out to me. Casey is amazingly talented.

  9. AI can’t handle James having disabilities & has tried to downgrade his talent. Shame on AI for NOT supporting James. James is an inspiration for other people w disabilities. Shame that AI doesn’t allow family members to travel w the idols. Kudos to James for constantly doing the best that he can under the circumstances. Our family supports james & were there for his hometown concert, Santa Cruz! C

  10. My thoughts exactly on the way James has been treated on this tour. Who knows who made the decision (Jimmy?) but it’s clear he is being punished for something. Maybe it was the Gaga thing. She doesn’t seem like someone who would care but I doubt Jimmy would take kindly to his biggest star being dissed. When James had an opportunity later on, he brought her up again, & it seemed like she had become an issue for him & he did seem a little bitter about it. Well, I don’t care about what he said, but I guess he will have to learn to zip it. Still, he is one of the biggest stars on Idol this summer, and it has been noticed by many. He is a gifted performer. And this Wind-Up deal sounds like a great fit for him. Signing with Interscope would have mean too much compromise for him. Rock on James.

    • I don’t know who made the decision either , but with someone as talented , brave and loving as James some forgiveness might have been offered with words of caution and the TPTB could have moved on and done what was in the best interest of James and ultimately the show. The audience after all is paying good money for the best that it can be!! This show left a lot of potential , spectacular entertainment on the cutting floor!

  11. Actually, I think Jacob has also been treated badly, and hardly anyone seems to care. First, he has to follow James, and that just doesn’t work. And he finished 5th and he doesn’t get a duet either.

    • You are absolutely right about Jacob and from what I can tell from the videos his performance skills have improved a lot and he can be very entertaining too. Even though this is a site for James and his fans, anyone from other fanbases is welcome to vent here provided they don’t bash James and the other posters here while doing so.

  12. What a wonderful review, and I do hope that the producer of AI read it! Definitely not enough of James on tour. I was concern for a while James didn’t look very happy on some of the performances.

    Kathryn, I have to share something with you, other than James voice and his ability to rock the stage. His hand movements mesmerize me. I know that this will sound funny to many, but I think you will understand. I don’t know why I notice this so much. I love the way he holds the Mic, often times it’s like his hands are singing too. His hands are just beautifully used and so usual for a guy who’s into rock. As an example, the video of the studio session in Orlando (wearing his purple-fringed jacket) his hands are so intense. Also, at the end of the sweet child of mine, towards the end of the song when he raises his hand so elegantly poised. It’s like when he hits the stage every part his body is performing, and every part knows exactly what to do!

    I would appreciate your take on this Kathryn. Thanks for all your comments; you have made me see and hear things that I never gave thought to! Thanks so much for sharing with us.

    • Hi Nancy,

      You make a very good point. James is what we call in the classical world a prodigy. That is someone who is a fully developed artist with little if any prior training. (Jackie Evancho is an 11 year old prodigy that you should hear- now managed by David Foster). As Webster defines it a prodigy is a marvel, a wonder, someone extraordinary! And James is all of that. The ease with which he moves about the stage, his vocals, his emotional awareness and the comfort level within himself to sing and perform is just breath taking to someone like me who has lived and breathed performance since 8 years of age. The music sings James.

      This level of organic performance cannot be taught. It just is! As he has said the ideas just “come” to him. He plans where he wants to be on stage to be sure, but even that can change with someone as creative and as spontaneous as James. What he did on Friday night in Baltimore with his small portion of the Whitesnake song is an example. Lauren was unable to sing so he made it his own with very little time to prepare and he owned it from the first note to the last. One of the things that makes him such a complete performer is that ALL of him is engaged when he performs – that includes his facial expressions, his eyes and his limbs. He doesn’t even think about it. The movement and the music cannot be separated. As Jennifer said, he goes away when he performs.

      The judges tried to tell the public about his amazing gifts. Many understood. But many were blind; and still others were threatened and despised him for it. No matter. James gifts will remain regardless of any slings and arrows hurled his way. Ultimately, surrounded by family, friends, mentors and fans who love and cherish him, James’ journey personally and professionally will be between him and the One who has blessed him!!!

      We are merely observers!

  13. Kathryn, still looking forward to your review of James’ ‘rendition of “Change is Gonna Come” and the rest of the interview. Looking forward to more fun to keep the Durb batteries charged! 🙂 Thanks for the great comments, Ellie

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s